Comments on: Meeting expectations for muni wi-fi http://www.brad-stone.com/2006/06/08/meeting-expectations-for-city-wide-wi-fi/ The articles, cartoons and occasional misspellings of San Francisco journalist Brad Stone Tue, 06 Jan 2009 07:49:06 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.0 by: Kimo Crossman http://www.brad-stone.com/2006/06/08/meeting-expectations-for-city-wide-wi-fi/#comment-6 Sun, 11 Jun 2006 10:35:42 +0000 http://www.brad-stone.com/2006/06/08/meeting-expectations-for-city-wide-wi-fi/#comment-6 I think finally people are seeing the light on Muni Wifi - thanks for your coverage. The Indoor coverage issue is bigger than acknowledged: If outdoors based Muni WiFi is going to be ad supported then one needs eyeballs - where do people use their computers the large majority of the time? OOPS Indoors. SF asked for 90% indoor coverage - (not just for perimeter rooms that have windows or are below the 2nd floor). CPE isn't going to get a signal typically above 2nd floor and nonethless you gotta have a window or rooftop facing a transmitter - otherwise you probably can't even draw in WiFi. Who wants to check their email in their PJ's in the middle of the night by taking their laptop outside and standing under a lightpole? If the city is going to provide exclusive access for a ISP like Earthlink/Google for their Vertical Assets (Earthlink asked for 10 years + 8 year extension) Basically a WiFi monopoly franchise then it is only politically viable if everyone gets similar coverage - otherwise you haven't solved the Digital Divide buzzword SF TechConnect WiFi Franchise: City hearing Monday 6/12 10am PST - watch live online too How will your privacy be protected? Can we get more than 300k speed (Mtn Vw gets 1000k) Digital Inclusion funding (philly got 10,000 computers) How well will it work indoors (SF asked for 90% indoor coverage) Will there be significant Pilots before the contract is signed? You can also watch online live streaming at SFGTV http://sfgov.org/site/sfgtv_index.asp?id=11463 Agenda: http://www.sfgov.org/site/bdsupvrs_page.asp?id=29796 I think finally people are seeing the light on Muni Wifi - thanks for your coverage.

The Indoor coverage issue is bigger than acknowledged:

If outdoors based Muni WiFi is going to be ad supported then one needs eyeballs - where do people use their computers the large majority of the time? OOPS Indoors. SF asked for 90% indoor coverage - (not just for perimeter rooms that have windows or are below the 2nd floor). CPE isn’t going to get a signal typically above 2nd floor and nonethless you gotta have a window or rooftop facing a transmitter - otherwise you probably can’t even draw in WiFi.

Who wants to check their email in their PJ’s in the middle of the night by taking their laptop outside and standing under a lightpole?

If the city is going to provide exclusive access for a ISP like Earthlink/Google for their Vertical Assets (Earthlink asked for 10 years + 8 year extension) Basically a WiFi monopoly franchise then it is only politically viable if everyone gets similar coverage - otherwise you haven’t solved the Digital Divide buzzword

SF TechConnect WiFi Franchise: City hearing Monday 6/12 10am PST - watch live online too

How will your privacy be protected?
Can we get more than 300k speed (Mtn Vw gets 1000k)
Digital Inclusion funding (philly got 10,000 computers)
How well will it work indoors (SF asked for 90% indoor coverage)
Will there be significant Pilots before the contract is signed?

You can also watch online live streaming at SFGTV http://sfgov.org/site/sfgtv_index.asp?id=11463

Agenda: http://www.sfgov.org/site/bdsupvrs_page.asp?id=29796

]]>